Suffragettes, Circuses, tigers and journalists: a bizarre jaunt around Victorian London in The Hourglass Factory

Book Reviews, Book Thoughts, London, Writing

IMG_8738 Frankie George is sent by her newspaper for her first proper piece – a profile of suffragette-trapeze artist Ebony Diamond. But while she’s on the trail, Ebony lashes out at her then disappears mysteriously in the middle of her performance. Frankie gains a snake-charmer and dubious errand boy as sidekicks along the way as well as meeting a vast variety of characters, and quest to find Miss Diamond uncovers plots and secrets that she would never have dreamt of. 

I really, really, wanted to really really like this book. I started reading it just before Christmas, and with Victorian London, Suffragettes, circuses, plots, mysteries and journalists I was anticipating a novel of complete delight. And true, some of it was there. The plot swung around a huge variety of intriguing settings, bizarre twists and colourful characters – but for me, ultimately, this novel was lacking.

The plot uncovered excitingly and sufficiently misleadingly, the many pieces gradually coming together at the end. I was held enough by the mystery to keep reading despite my frustrations, though I do find that at the end I’m still not quite sure how it all came about.

I also LOVED the jaunts around London. Now that I live here I recognised a large portion of the street names that were mentioned, and loved to be able to imagine the characters in a place that I actually know. The setting was fun!

Probably the main obstacle to my enjoying it was the main character. Frankie is obtuse, circumspect about her past, and to me, rather unlike-able. I just couldn’t work her out at all – is she very ambitious, or just too lazy? Passionate about women’s rights or indifferent? Lesbian or not? Her complexities were presumably meant to keep us hanging throughout the book, but I mainly found that I didn’t care.

Which was a real shame, because really I would have liked to be on her side. She’s a female journalist in Victorian London, for goodness sake – you would have thought I could easily get alongside. But instead I found myself wishing that Ebony Diamond, perhaps, was the main character of the book.

Another thing this would have helped was the desire I had to see more of the inner workings of the suffragettes. I realised that I’ve never read any books based on them, whereas I would be very very interested to. And indeed, I was here – so this felt a bit like a waste of an incredible subject matter.

So it was a good book, but not quite as good as I hoped. And if Frankie George plans to reappear for any more books I’d need to see some serious development in her character to be convinced.

Thanks to Netgalley for the ARC.

One thought on “Suffragettes, Circuses, tigers and journalists: a bizarre jaunt around Victorian London in The Hourglass Factory

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s